This was a Ray that came to the surface and swam around at dusk but unfortunately I didn't have my proper camera with me. Two local fishermen who we where with us said this is a String Ray. In this light it looked a beige / light brown colour with an elongated tail and flapped it's wings as it swam.
Please help me identify this. I can’t tell if it’s a dogfish or a small black tip but I’m pretty sure it’s a dogfish. Caught in New Jersey.